i m actualy not the right person to reply may be cuz im not a pure muslim my self ,
but to comment on some one, u should know what they r trying to do n we are no one to comment on their iman!
sab se pehle to i totaly agreed with farrys comment here
~Unknown~
ok now, let me get it straight kyu k mera khud ka talluk music ki feild se hai n i never comment on the thread like this ta k khuda na khwasta koi mujh per hi log fatwa na laga dein. kyu k me is field se bht close raha hun to i know
what exactly the music is!
ok now let me ask u guys
WHAT IS MUSIC?
im sure sab ye kahenge it is haram n all per defination of music bht kam log hi samjh sake
let me tell u that actualy
MUSIC IS NOT HARAM in ISLAM!
Y?
now before passing a fatwa towards me let me explain what is music?
music is a form of comunication.
music sirf wo nai jo singers songs ga rahe hain ya clubs me songs chal rahe hain ya yehi sab!
music is what we call tilawat. tilawat bhi ek music ki tune me hoti hai so it is a form of music. nasheed bhi usi ka hissa hai.jab ap azan sunte ho ek tune me wo bhi music hai.
yaha me ab detail me nai jata.
now the only problem n debate jo raha hai salo se music ko le ker islam me wo ye hai k is k lyrics.
n is ka usage.
me ye nai kehta k jis tarha ka music me kerta hun (like love poetry n all that)
it is not right acording to islam. but is se bhi zada bura jab hota hai jab lyrics me shirk ho, kyu k shirk zina se bhi bara gunah hai.
ap us music ko to chor hi de jis ko sun ker ap jhoom rahe ho ya dance ker rahe ho wo to already out hai islam kya koi bhi danishmand log use like bhi nai kerte n kerna bhi nai chaiye.
nasheed singers like juniad n ahmed bukhatir (jo dono hi meri khud k city sharjah n karachi se hain) dono ko me bht achi tarha janta hun.
islam ka daromadar ek sab se eham cheez per hai neeyat!
ager ap ki neeyat saaf hai or ap apni beautiful voice se islam phelana chahte hain (im not talking about guitar nasheed like sami yosuf) but let alone these two well known nasheed singers jin k naats n nasheed me completely koi instruments use nai hote just vocals ko different different ways me use ker k software k zariye nasheed ko beautiful way me banaya jata hai, n its as long as im concern is me koi buri bat nai.
now ye alag bat hai k ap is per belive karein ya nai, esi bht c cheeze hain jo us zamane me nahi thi, so dierectly use haraam ka tag lagana theek nai.
ab kuch scholars to TV ko bhi haram kehte hain ?
jab k TV se bhi ager correct istemal lia jae to deen ko phelane ka acha zariya hai,
ap log ye bataien ap log net use kerte hain kai scholars to ise bhi waqt ka zaya kehte hain n kai to ise bhi haraam kehte hain?
jab k net se bhi ager sirf apna focus deeni or islami kamo me lagae to net use kerne me kya harj hai?
im sorry to say but hum sab ko chaiye k pehle apna iman pukhta karien, in bareekio ko jin per abhi bhi ? mark hai is ko apni apni taraf se haram halal kehne k bajae jin cheezo ka waze bataya gaya hai pehle us me to apne ap ko pura utaro, like namaz roza haj zakat or sab se main cheez apne ikhlak or apne ander ki insan ko behtreen insan banain.
yehi wajha hai ka aj musalam ek dosre per fatwa laga rahe hain n musalmano me dange fasad peda ho rahe hain.
i know meri bat se bht se log itefak nai karenge n me yaha unhe apni bat manwane nai aya hun bul k tasweer ka dosra rukh dikhane aya hun cuz me khud music ki feild se talluk rakhta hun (jo k mera personal matter hai jo mere or mere Allah k bich hai) in cheezo ko mujhse better koi nia smajh sakta.