Thank U Teachel agar mere sentences main koi ghalti ho tou plz spot kijiye ga so i can correct it....
welcome in [DOUBLEPOST=1356003504][/DOUBLEPOST]New Enrollment!
itna mushklwelcome in [DOUBLEPOST=1356003504][/DOUBLEPOST]
He said to me, “What are you doing?”
which one will be the correct option if we change this direct speech into indirect form also mention the reason and rule!
He said to me,"what i was doing"?
He asked me,"What are you doing?"
He asked me that what i was doing.
He asked me what i was doing.
@Sabah @ChoCo @Qawareer @Nelly @Sparkofighter @Mahen
okay thora soucny dw phly hi brain mein kuch nhi rhta dakti hwhyelaa nae aasan hay
ok take ur timeokay thora soucny dw phly hi brain mein kuch nhi rhta dakti hw
i thinkwelcome in [DOUBLEPOST=1356003504][/DOUBLEPOST]
He said to me, “What are you doing?”
which one will be the correct option if we change this direct speech into indirect form also mention the reason and rule!
He said to me,"what i was doing"?
He asked me,"What are you doing?"
He asked me that what i was doing.
He asked me what i was doing.
@Sabah @ChoCo @Qawareer @Nelly @Sparkofighter @Mahen
your answer is correct but I have to mention here that in reported speech said can not be change in all situations except the intterogative statements it changes from said to asked for describing the intterogation.i think
He said to me, “What are you doing?” iss ka answer ye hai
He asked me what i was doing.
cos reporting question sentence hai orr iss mein said ko asked, inquired etc mein change krty hai inn dono ka meaning same hota hai asked orr inquired ka but use sentence ko dak kr hi kia jaye ga orr jab isy indirect mein change kr dye gie tou iss ka question mark khtam hw jaye ga
am i right?
He asked me what i was doing , i guess i think we did this ages bakk in this thread or may be in a different one, so i remember this technique thora thora.....welcome in [DOUBLEPOST=1356003504][/DOUBLEPOST]
which one will be the correct option if we change this direct speech into indirect form also mention the reason and rule!
- He said to me, “What are you doing?”
@Sabah @ChoCo @Qawareer @Nelly @Sparkofighter @Mahen
- He said to me,"what i was doing"?
- He asked me,"What are you doing?"
- He asked me that what i was doing.
- He asked me what i was doing.
the 4th option seems a relevant reply.
4- He asked me What I was doing.
Note: said changes to asked because the direct speech is an interrogative sentence.[DOUBLEPOST=1356014708][/DOUBLEPOST]
your answer is correct but I have to mention here that in reported speech said can not be change in all situations except the intterogative statements it changes from said to asked for describing the intterogation.
for example:
simple tense
direct speech:- "I like it" he said.
indirect speech:- "he said he liked it".
intterogative sentence
direct speech:- He said to me, “What are you doing?”
indirect speech:- He asked me what i was doing.
I hope you got it.
i think
He said to me, “What are you doing?” iss ka answer ye hai
He asked me what i was doing.
cos reporting question sentence hai orr iss mein said ko asked, inquired etc mein change krty hai inn dono ka meaning same hota hai asked orr inquired ka but use sentence ko dak kr hi kia jaye ga orr jab isy indirect mein change kr dye gie tou iss ka question mark khtam hw jaye ga
am i right?
answer sab ka theek hayHe asked me what i was doing , i guess i think we did this ages bakk in this thread or may be in a different one, so i remember this technique thora thora.....
yeah issi thread may kiya thaHe asked me what i was doing , i guess i think we did this ages bakk in this thread or may be in a different one, so i remember this technique thora thora.....
Ohhhh yesss months backkkk n thanks for explaining misssanswer sab ka theek hay
lemme explain it a bit more!
when for direct speech u r using a simple sentence(not interrogative)
for say
He said,"i like it"
the indirect form will be as follow (the rule of changing direct to indirect is,,,,,,
- see the first part of sentence and change the second part according to the tense used in the first part,,,
- remove all commas
- add That after said.
He said that he liked it.(when ever u have to remove the inverted commas after said, "That" must be added as a bridge between both parts of the sentence,
He said That i liked it. no comma will be used in indirect speech.
if u r replacing said with Asked/reported/inquired etc there is no need of adding "That".
for interrogative!
he said to me," what i am doing?"
He asked me what i was doing. (no need of adding that after asked/inquired etc)
interrogative sentence hay to obviously inquired ya asked most suitable hain to replace said,,,,, sentence k first part may past tense hay "said to me" to accordingly hamain sentence ka next part b past tense ki hi kisi form may change karna hoga!
Chlain next Aap may se koi dain [DOUBLEPOST=1356057119][/DOUBLEPOST]
yeah issi thread may kiya tha
not ages back,,,months back nellu
always welcomeOhhhh yesss months backkkk n thanks for explaining misss
nxt b same direct indirect ka kuch dena hai, ya it could b anything???